POINT BY POINT OUTLINE
Prepared by Rabbi P. Feldman of Kollel Iyun Hadaf, Yerushalayim daf@dafyomi.co.il http://www.dafyomi.co.il
1) WHO WROTE THE SEFARIM (cont.)
(a) Yirmiyahu wrote Sefer Yirmiyahu, Melachim and Eichah;
(b) Chizkiyahu and his contemporaries wrote Yeshayah,
Mishlei, Shir ha'Shirim and Koheles;
(c) The men of the Great Assembly wrote Yechezkel, the 12,
Daniel and Megilas Esther;
(d) Ezra wrote Sefer Ezra, and the lineage at the beginning
of Divrei ha'Yamim until himself (Rashi; Tosfos - until
the verse "v'Lo Achim Benei Yehoshafat");
1. This supports Rav, who said that Ezra did not
leave Bavel until he established his own lineage.
2. Question: Who finished Divrei ha'Yamim?
3. Answer: Nechemyah did.
(e) (Beraisa): Yehoshua wrote Sefer Yehoshua and the last
eight verses of the Torah.
(f) Tana'im argue about whether Moshe or Yehoshua wrote the
last eight verses.
1. (Beraisa - R. Yehudah or R. Nechemyah): Moshe
could not have written "va'Yamas Sham Moshe"!
i. Rather, Moshe wrote until here. Yehoshua wrote
the rest.
2. Objection (R. Shimon): Had Moshe omitted even one
letter of the Torah, it would not say "Lako'ach Es
Sefer ha'Torah ha'Zeh"!
i. Rather, until here, Hash-m dictated the Torah
and Moshe wrote;
ii. For these last eight verses, Hash-m
dictated and Moshe wrote b'Dema (with tears;
Sefas Emes - he wrote the letters without
spaces between words).
3. Similarly, Yirmiyahu dictated his prophecy to
Baruch (who wrote it; Rashi - similarly, Baruch did
not repeat the verses due to remorse) - "mi'Piv
Yikra Elai... va'Ani Kosev."
(g) Question: Like whom is the following teaching?
1. (R. Yehoshua bar Aba): One person reads the last
eight verses (i.e. we do not split the reading among
two people).
2. Suggestion: It is not R. Shimon. He holds that
Moshe wrote them, so they should be the same as the
rest of the Torah!
(h) Answer: No, it is even like R. Shimon;
1. He admits that Moshe wrote them differently,
therefore they have a special status.
(i) Question: We cannot say that Yehoshua wrote Sefer
Yehoshua. It says "va'Yamas Yehoshua"!
(j) Answer: Elazar finished it.
(k) Question: It says "v'Elazar ben Aharon Mes"!
(l) Answer: Pinchas finished it.
(m) Question: We cannot say that Shmuel wrote Sefer Shmuel.
It says "u'Shmuel Mes"!
(n) Answer: Gad and Nasan finished it.
(o) (Beraisa): David and ten other Chachamim wrote Tehilim.
(p) Question: We should also include Eisan ha'Ezrachi (the
author of Tehilim 89)!
(q) Answer: That is Avraham, like it says "Mi He'ir
mi'Mizrach".
(r) Question: The Beraisa counts Moshe and Heiman. Rav said
that Heiman is Moshe - "b'Chol Beisi Ne'eman Hu"!
(s) Answer: Moshe is Heiman, but Heiman ha'Ezrachi (the
author of Tehilim 88) is someone else.
2) WHEN DID IYOV LIVE?
(a) (Beraisa): Moshe wrote the Torah, including the Parshah
of Bilam, and Sefer Iyov.
(b) This supports Rav Levi bar Lachma.
1. (Rav Levi bar Lachma): Iyov lived in Moshe's day.
It says "Mi Yiten Efo", similar to what Moshe said,
"uva'Meh Yivada Efo".
2. Question: Perhaps he lived in the time of
Yitzchak (who said "Mi Efo") or Yakov (who said "Efo
Zos Asu") or Yosef (who asked "Eifo Hem Ro'im")?!
3. Answer: It also says in Iyov, "...v'Yuchaku".
Moshe is called Mechokek.
(c) (Rava): Iyov was in the days of the Meraglim (spies).
Iyov lived "b'Eretz Utz", similar to "ha'Yesh Bah Etz."
(d) Objection: 'Utz' and 'Etz' are different!
(e) Answer: Moshe asked the spies to see if the one (Iyov)
whose years are great as a tree, and protects his
generation like a tree, is still alive. (This is another
answer to b:1.)
(f) (A Chacham): Iyov never lived, Sefer Iyov is only a
parable.
(g) Rejection (Rav Shmuel bar Nachmani): "Ish Hayah" - he
did live!
1. Question: "Kivsah Achas... va'Ychayeha" was only
a parable!
2. Answer: If Iyov was only a parable, it would not
give his name and his city's name.
(h) (R. Yochanan and R. Elazar): Iyov returned with the
exiles from Bavel. His Beis Medrash was in Tiverya.
(i) Question (Beraisa): Iyov lived from when Yisrael
descended to Miztrayim until they left.
15b----------------------------------------15b
(j) Answer: It means, Iyov lived as long as the time from
when Yisrael descended to Miztrayim until they left (210
years).
(k) Question (Beraisa): Seven Nevi'im from other nations
prophesized: Bilam and his father, Iyov, Elifaz
ha'Temani, Bildad ha'Shuchi, Tzufar ha'Na'amasi, and
Elihu ben Barach'el ha'Buzi. (This shows that Iyov was
not a Yisrael!)
1. Counter-question: If so, also Elihu ben Barach'el
was not a Yisrael. However, it says that he was from
the family of Ram (i.e. Avraham! Alternatively, the
verse would not give the lineage of a Nochri!
Ya'avetz - really, he descended from Buz ben Nachor,
Avraham's nephew. This is why he is called ha'Buzi.)
(l) Answer (to both questions): Rather, the Beraisa means
that seven Nevi'im prophesized to the other nations.
(m) Question: All the Nevi'im prophesized for all the
nations!
(n) Answer: The prophecies of these seven were primarily
for the other nations.
(o) Question (Beraisa): There was a Chasid of the other
nations; he came to the world only to get his reward;
1. Hash-m brought punishments upon him. He
blasphemed, so Hash-m doubled his reward in this
world to deprive him of his reward in the world to
come.
(p) Answer: Tana'im argue about whether or not he was a
Yisrael.
1. (Beraisa - R. Eliezer): Iyov was in the days of
the Shoftim;
i. It says "Hevel Tehavlu" - this is the generation
that judged its judges.
2. R. Yehoshua ben Korchah says, he was in the days
of Achashverosh - "v'Lo Nimzta Nashim Yafos.. b'Chol
ha'Aretz";
i. In Achashverosh's day they sought the most
beautiful women.
ii. Question: They did also in David's day!
iii. Answer: Then, they searched only in Eretz
Yisrael, but not in the whole world.
3. R. Nasan says, he was in the days of Malkas (the
kingdom of) Sheva - "va'Tipol Sheva."
4. Chachamim say, he was in the days of Kasdim
(Babylonians, i.e. Nebuchadnetzar) - "Kasdim...
Hiku..."
5. Some say, he was in the days of Yakov, and
married Dinah;
i. It says "k'Daber Achas ha'Nevalos", like it
says about Dinah "Nevalah Asah b'Yisrael."
6. All the opinions except the last must hold that
Iyov was a Yisrael, since they say that he lived
after Moshe; (Maharsha - even Yakov's descendants
were not considered 'Yisrael' until Matan Torah.
Alternatively, it is unreasonable that his
descendant would marry her.) (Perhaps this is
unreasonable, for Utz (where Iyov lived) is not
Mitzrayim, and we cannot say that Iyov was afflicted
(at the age of 70) before all Bnei Yisrael descended
to Mitzrayim (Yakov had no son above 46 at the
time), nor was it after Bnei Yisrael entered Eretz
Yisrael (Rashi Bamidbar 26:46 implies that Dinah
died before this - PF).)
i. Moshe requested that Hash-m not give prophecy
to Nochrim, and Hash-m agreed - "v'Niflinu...
mi'Kol ha'Am."
(q) (R. Yochanan): The generation of Iyov was steeped in
lewdness;
1. It says "Kulchem Chazisem", similar to
"v'Nechezeh Bach" (looking at a woman).
2. Suggestion: Perhaps it means to see through
prophecy, like it says "Chazon Yeshayahu"!
3. Rejection: (The verse continues) "Hevel Tehbalu."
(r) (R. Yochanan): "Bi'Mei Shefot ha'Shoftim" refers to a
generation that judged its judges;
1. If a judge would rebuke someone for a small
transgression, the person would rebuke the judge for
a great transgression.
(s) (Rav Shmuel bar Nachmani): Malkas Sheva was not a
woman, rather it is the kingdom of Sheva.
3) THE GREATNESS OF IYOV
(a) "Va'Ya'an ha'Satan" - the Satan told Hash-m that he did
not see anyone in the world as faithful as Avraham;
1. Even though Hash-m told Avraham that he will give
to him Eretz Yisrael, and Avraham could not find a
burial place for Sarah until he paid 400 Shekalim,
he did not resent this. (A typical yearly income was
50 Shekalim. Efron demanded coins 100 times bigger
than standard Shekalim (Rashi Bereishis 23:16).)
(b) Hash-m told the Satan to consider Iyov.
(c) (R. Yochanan): The verse praises Iyov more than
Avraham!
1. Regarding Avraham it says "Yerei Elokim."
Regarding Iyov it says "Ish Tam v'Yashar Yerei
Elokim v'Sar me'Ra";
2. Question: What does it mean "v'Sar me'Ra"?
3. Answer (R. Aba bar Shmuel): He was easygoing with
his money;
i. Normally, if one owes half a Perutah (the
smallest coin is a Perutah), he buys something
for a Perutah and shares it with the one he
owes. Iyov would give the full Perutah.
(d) Question: "The Satan answered... 'Ma'ase Yadav
Berachta."' What does this mean?
(e) Answer (Rav Shmuel bar Rav Yitzchak): Anyone who
received a Perutah from Iyov was blessed.
(f) Question: What does it mean "u'Miknehu Paratz
ba'Aretz"?
(g) Answer (R. Yosi b'Rebbi Chanina): Iyov's flock
overstepped nature;
1. Normally, wolves kill goats; Iyov's flock killed
wolves.
(h) The Satan thought that if Iyov's prosperity ceased, he
would blaspheme. Hash-m authorized the Satan to do as he
wishes to it.
(i) Question: "The cattle were plowing and the donkeys were
grazing Al Yedeihem." What does this mean?
(j) Answer (R. Yochanan): (The fodder grew instantly.)
Hash-m gave Iyov a taste of the world to come.
Next Daf
Index to Outlines for Maseches Bava Basra |